Forgiveness Before Thanksgiving: Taking the First Step Toward the Person You Can’t Forgive
Have you ever caught yourself in the car having a full-blown argument with someone who isn’t there? You make your case point by point. You anticipate every objection. And you win, every single time, in an argument the other person doesn’t even know is happening.
Thanksgiving is only days away, and for many of us, there will be someone at the table we haven’t forgiven. It might be a parent, a sibling, or an ex. It might be an adult child who stopped calling, a friend who broke a confidence, or a church leader who let you down. Just picturing them across the table is enough to tighten your stomach.
If a name came to mind as you read that, this article is for you.
We Believe in Forgiveness. Why Is It So Hard to Do?
Jesus spoke about forgiveness with startling directness. In Matthew 6:14–15 (NIV), He said, “For if you forgive other people when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you do not forgive others their sins, your Father will not forgive your sins.”
Christians talk about forgiveness more than almost anyone. We sing about it, preach about it, and agree that it matters. Yet research on forgiveness has found that while believers tend to value forgiveness more highly than others, that doesn’t always translate into forgiving more in practice. Believing in forgiveness and actually forgiving turn out to be two very different things.
So what makes the difference? One of the strongest predictors of whether people forgive others isn’t how often they attend church or even how much they pray. It’s whether they genuinely feel forgiven by God. People who know how much they’ve been forgiven find it easier to extend that same mercy to others.
That points to a deeper issue. Often, we struggle to forgive because the wound has started telling us who we are. When someone rejects, betrays, or abandons us, we can draw conclusions: I’m not worth keeping. Nothing good lasts. I can’t trust anyone. We may not walk around angry, but we walk around guarded. And it is very hard to forgive from a place where our identity feels bankrupt.
That’s why 1 John 3:1 (NIV) matters so much here: “See what great love the Father has lavished on us, that we should be called children of God! And that is what we are!” John doesn’t say that’s what we’re working toward. He says that’s what we already are. Before anyone hurt you, and before you accomplished anything, God called you His child. Forgiveness grows best from that secure place.
What Forgiveness Is and Isn’t
Part of the reason forgiveness feels impossible is that many of us misunderstand what it requires. Colossians 3:13 (NIV) gives the standard: “Bear with each other and forgive one another if any of you has a grievance against someone. Forgive as the Lord forgave you.”
How did the Lord forgive us? He treated our sin as real. He paid its full cost Himself on the cross. And then He released us from the debt, never to hold it against us again. Seeing forgiveness this way clears up several common misunderstandings:
Forgiveness is not pretending it didn’t hurt. Jesus never asks us to act as though a real wound is no big deal. Forgiveness is not calling wrong right. What happened may have been deeply wrong, and forgiving doesn’t change that. And forgiveness is not the same as restoring trust or access. You can forgive someone without handing them the keys to hurt you again. If someone is unsafe, forgiving them doesn’t mean putting yourself back in harm’s way.
So what does forgiveness involve? It begins with honest lament, bringing every part of the hurt to God, who already knows it and can handle all of it. Then it means releasing the debt: choosing to hand over what the other person owes you and trusting God with the outcome. And it often includes a harder step: looking honestly at how we responded to the hurt. Bitterness can show up as gossip, harsh words, overwork, or other unhealthy ways of coping. Forgiveness and repentance often travel together.
How can you tell whether forgiveness has taken root? Listen to your words. If you say you’ve forgiven someone but still describe them with contempt, something is still unresolved. Jesus said that the mouth speaks what fills the heart (see Matthew 12:34). Another sign is whether you can sincerely ask God to bless the person, without gritting your teeth.
When the Apology Never Comes
The hardest forgiveness of all may be forgiving someone who has never said they’re sorry, and probably never will. Maybe they don’t even realize what they did. Meanwhile, you replay the moment for months or even years, and it seems to grow worse each time.
Jesus faced this. From the cross, surrounded by people who mocked Him, He prayed, “Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they are doing” (Luke 23:34, NIV). No one at the foot of the cross apologized. Jesus forgave first.
Waiting for an apology can keep us stuck for years. But forgiveness doesn’t depend on the other person’s response. As we bring our hurt to God, we often begin to see the person who hurt us differently. People who hurt others are often carrying wounds of their own. Seeing them with compassion doesn’t excuse what they did, but it can free us to pray for them rather than resent them. Sometimes the most honest prayer we can offer is simply Jesus’ own words over their name: Father, forgive them. We can say it before we feel it, trusting God to make it true in us over time.
Remember What You’ve Been Forgiven
Jesus told a parable about a servant who owed his king a debt he could never repay. When the servant begged for mercy, the king canceled the entire debt. Then the servant walked out, found someone who owed him a small amount, and had him thrown into prison. When the king heard, he called the servant back: “You wicked servant,” he said, “I canceled all that debt of yours because you begged me to. Shouldn’t you have had mercy on your fellow servant just as I had on you?” (Matthew 18:32–33, NIV).
The servant’s problem wasn’t a lack of effort. It was a failure to remember. He forgot how much he had been forgiven. That’s why feeling forgiven by God is such a powerful foundation for forgiving others. When we remember the mercy we’ve received, mercy begins to flow out of us.
Four Steps to Take Before You Sit Down at the Table
You don’t have to resolve every hurt before Thanksgiving. But you can take a first step:
Name one person. Write down the name of someone you need to forgive. You can’t forgive what you won’t name.
Bring it all to God. Tell Him honestly what you lost and what you’ve believed about yourself because of it. Then ask, “What is true about me as Your child?”
Pray Jesus’ words. Say once, out loud, “Father, forgive them,” over that person’s name. You don’t need a feeling, a phone call, or a conversation. Just pray it.
Put your debt beside theirs. Next to the name, write one thing God has forgiven you for. Look at the two side by side, and carry that paper with you to the table as a quiet reminder of the mercy you’ve received.
A Thankful Heart Starts With Forgiveness
Forgiveness may not happen all at once. For deep wounds, it is often a process rather than a single moment, and that’s okay. What matters is taking the next step. When you sit down at the table this Thanksgiving, you don’t have to pretend nothing happened or force a reconciliation. You simply have to remember how much you’ve been forgiven, and let that mercy shape how you see the person across from you. Few things will make your heart more thankful than that.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does forgiving someone mean I have to reconcile with them?
No. Forgiveness releases the debt someone owes you; reconciliation requires trust to be rebuilt, which takes time and changed behavior. You can forgive someone while still keeping healthy boundaries. If someone is unsafe, talk with a pastor or counselor about how to protect yourself.
How can I forgive someone who has never apologized?
Forgiveness doesn’t depend on the other person’s response. Jesus forgave from the cross before anyone apologized (Luke 23:34). Bring your hurt honestly to God, release what they owe you into His hands, and pray for them, even before your feelings catch up.
How do I know if I’ve truly forgiven someone?
Pay attention to your words and your prayers. If you still speak about the person with contempt, or can’t sincerely ask God to bless them, there may be more to work through. Forgiveness of deep wounds is often a process, so be patient and keep bringing it to God.
If you’re looking for encouragement, clarity, and practical ways to grow stronger in your faith, we invite you to listen to the Spiritually Fit Today podcast. You can find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or YouTube, wherever you get your podcasts. Each episode is designed to help you take one step, one choice, one spiritual rep at a time, because what you do today matters.
Explore resources to strengthen your daily spiritual foundation at Back to the Bible.
Need prayer or guidance? Connect with our team on our Contact Page.




Comments