Forgiveness: The Hardest Command and the Deepest Freedom

There is a command in Scripture that is easier to preach than to obey, and every Christian eventually feels the weight of it. The command is to forgive. We hear it often enough. We nod along when it is taught. We agree with it in principle. And then someone wounds us in a way we did not expect, and we discover how deep the resistance runs in the human heart to actually do what Christ has commanded. Forgiveness is one of the most demanding acts a Christian is ever called to perform, and it is also one of the most freeing. The two go together. What costs us the most is what sets us most fully free.

Jesus made the command explicit. In the Sermon on the Mount, He said, "For if you forgive others their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you, but if you do not forgive others their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses" (Matthew 6:14–15). That is a serious statement, and it is delivered as a matter-of-fact truth. The forgiveness we receive and the forgiveness we extend are linked in the economy of God. This does not mean we earn God’s forgiveness by our own. It means that the person who has genuinely received grace from God will show grace to others, and the person who refuses to show grace demonstrates that they have not really understood the grace they claim to have received.

Peter came to Jesus once and asked how many times he should forgive a brother who sinned against him. Perhaps he thought he was being generous when he suggested seven times. Jesus answered, "I do not say to you seven times, but seventy-seven times" (Matthew 18:22). Some translations render it seventy times seven. Either way, the point is the same. Forgiveness is not a limited resource that eventually runs out. It is a continual posture of the heart, extended again and again toward those who wound us, because it reflects the character of the God who has extended it endlessly to us.

Jesus then told a story that every Christian should read carefully. A servant owed a king ten thousand talents, which was a debt so large it could never be repaid in a lifetime. The king ordered the servant and his family to be sold. The servant fell down and begged for patience. The king was moved with pity, released him, and forgave the debt entirely. That servant then went out and found another servant who owed him a hundred denarii, a modest sum. He seized the man by the throat, demanded payment, refused mercy, and had the man thrown into prison until he could pay. When the king heard about it, he called the first servant back. "You wicked servant! I forgave you all that debt because you pleaded with me. And should not you have had mercy on your fellow servant, as I had mercy on you?" (Matthew 18:32–33). The king delivered him to the jailers to be tormented.

Jesus then said something we should never let go of. "So also my heavenly Father will do to every one of you, if you do not forgive your brother from your heart" (Matthew 18:35). The parable is not an obscure teaching for the especially serious. It is a warning for every believer who has ever nursed a grudge, held on to a hurt, refused to extend the mercy they themselves have received in far greater measure. The debt God has forgiven us is infinitely larger than any debt anyone will ever owe us. To refuse the smaller mercy after receiving the greater is a spiritual condition Christ Himself calls wicked.

We should be honest about what makes forgiveness so hard. It requires us to release something. When we have been wronged, part of us wants justice. We want the person to feel what they made us feel. We want the wrong to be acknowledged, punished, corrected. Forgiveness feels like we are letting them off the hook, and the flesh recoils from that. It seems like a denial of the reality of the wrong, or an implicit statement that what they did did not matter. Understanding what forgiveness actually is, biblically, is the first step toward being able to offer it.

Forgiveness has often been misunderstood. It does not mean pretending the wrong did not happen or that it did not hurt or that it was acceptable. It is distinct from reconciliation, which requires the other party’s repentance and may or may not be possible. It is distinct from trust, which must be rebuilt over time when it has been broken. What forgiveness actually is, at its core, is the release of our right to hold the wrong against the other person, entrusting the judgment of it to God, and refusing to let the offense continue to define the relationship in our own hearts. It is what we do when we cannot make the wrong right on our own, and we bring it to the God who can, and we lay down our right to keep pressing for what only He can bring about.

Paul makes this pattern explicit. "Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God, for it is written, 'Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord'" (Romans 12:19). Forgiveness rests on the trust that justice is in the hands of a God who sees, knows, and will one day set every wrong right. Our part is not to serve as prosecutor, judge, and executioner in matters He has reserved for Himself. Our part is to entrust the situation to Him and to release the offender from the debt in our own hearts.

The pattern of Christian forgiveness is grounded in the forgiveness Christ Himself has shown us. Paul says it plainly. "Be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, as God in Christ forgave you" (Ephesians 4:32). And again, "Bearing with one another and, if one has a complaint against another, forgiving each other; as the Lord has forgiven you, so you also must forgive" (Colossians 3:13). The command is to forgive as we have been forgiven, and the model is Christ. That is a high standard, and it is the standard Scripture actually sets.

Consider how Christ forgave. He forgave us at cost. The blood of the Son of God was the price. He forgave us when we were still enemies (Romans 5:10). He did not wait for us to clean up our act, to earn our way back, to be worthy of His mercy. He extended it before we had any capacity to receive it, and He continues to extend it every time we fall. He forgave us fully. There is nothing held back, nothing kept in reserve, nothing waiting to be brought up again. Micah says God casts our sins into the depths of the sea (Micah 7:19). Isaiah says He blots them out and remembers them no more (Isaiah 43:25). That is what we have received, and that is the model for what we are called to extend.

This does not mean forgiveness is a single instantaneous event that we complete and never revisit. Deep wounds require ongoing forgiveness. The memory returns. The anger flares up. The temptation to rehearse the wrong comes back. And each time it does, the Christian is called to forgive again, to hand it back to the Lord, to refuse to pick up what we have already laid down.

Consider also the freedom that forgiveness brings. Unforgiveness is a prison. The person we refuse to forgive lives rent-free in our heads, occupying our thoughts, shaping our moods, coloring our other relationships. We think we are punishing them by holding on. We are almost always only punishing ourselves. The bitter person in the room is usually the one who kept the wrong alive long after the wounding was done. Every Christian who has forgiven someone from the heart has discovered the same thing. What felt like giving something up was really receiving something back. The freedom to move on. The freedom to sleep. The freedom to love others without the constant filter of past pain. Forgiveness releases the forgiven, and it also, in a very real sense, releases the one who forgives.

There is also the matter of forgiving ourselves, which some Christians struggle with more than forgiving others. If God has forgiven us through the blood of Christ, we have no right to hold ourselves in condemnation for what He has already dealt with at the cross. The person who refuses to receive the forgiveness God has extended is making a subtle claim that their sin is larger than the cross, that Christ’s blood was insufficient, that they know better than God how their debt should be handled. That is a form of pride hiding behind the appearance of contrition. If God has said we are forgiven, we are forgiven. The appropriate response is worship, gratitude, and the daily walking forward in the freedom He has purchased.

Perhaps you are reading this and there is someone specific you have been unable to forgive. The wound may be deep. The offense may be real. The other person may have done nothing to earn your forgiveness. That does not change the command. Christ is calling you to a freedom you cannot yet imagine, and the doorway to it is the release of what you have been holding. You do not have to feel it before you do it. You do not have to trust the other person. You do not even have to be in relationship with them. What you have to do is bring the offense before the Lord, entrust it to His justice, release your right to hold it against them, and ask Him to do in your heart what only He can do.

Christ prayed for the men who nailed Him to the cross. "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do" (Luke 23:34). If Christ could pray that from the cross, we can pray it from wherever we sit today. We are asked to walk in His steps, not our own. And the God who forgives us endlessly is the same God who gives us the power to forgive others, when we come to Him honestly, and let Him do the deep work of forgiveness in us that we cannot do on our own.

Forgive. It is the command of your Lord. It is the imitation of your Savior. It is the doorway to the freedom your soul has been longing for. Every act of forgiveness is a small victory of grace over the flesh, and every Christian who lives in it discovers that the deepest freedom in the Christian life is on the other side of the hardest command.

Join me on Back to the Bible Daily every weekday for bite-sized Bible teaching to center your day on God’s Word.