What Happened to Hell?
By Arnie Cole, CEO of Back to the Bible
Every survey has one question that ends up mattering more than the rest. When our research team at the Center for Scripture Absorption (CSA) put together the State of Christianity in America report, we asked Americans about Bible reading, prayer, church involvement, and how their faith shows up in daily life. But the question I keep coming back to is a simple one: When you die, where do you expect to spend eternity, and why?
I've been doing this kind of research for a long time, and the numbers rarely surprise me anymore. These answers did. I've talked them over with our staff, with pastors, and with friends around the dinner table, and I want to share them with you, along with what I believe Scripture says to the situation we're in.
What Americans Are Counting On
Here's what we found. Less than 1% of Americans expect to spend eternity in hell. Thirty-two percent expect to reach heaven because of their faith in Jesus. Twenty percent hope for heaven because they consider themselves a "good person." And 25% say they simply aren't sure what happens when they die.
I believe this question reveals more about the spiritual operating system of Americans than any other question on our SALT Index survey. It was a window into what people actually stake their lives on, not just what they affirm when a survey hands them a doctrinal sentence to agree with. What we're seeing isn't classical works-righteousness so much as moralistic therapeutic deism — the soft conviction that God grades on a curve, and that being decent, kind, and reasonably ethical is enough to cover the eternal ledger.
The Bible doesn't leave room for that kind of grading system. Paul writes that "all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God" (Romans 3:23). Notice that he doesn't sort people into the very bad and the reasonably decent. The standard is God's own glory, and every one of us has fallen short of it, the kind neighbor as much as anyone else. That's why, when Paul explains how we are saved, he is careful to say it is "not a result of works, so that no one may boast" (Ephesians 2:9). The verse just before tells us what salvation is instead: a gift from God, received by grace through faith (Ephesians 2:8). If our goodness could earn it, it would be a wage rather than a gift, and we would have something to boast about.
The 20% who are hoping their goodness will be enough aren't villains. Most of them are people I'd be glad to have as neighbors. But they're trusting in something Scripture says cannot carry the weight they're putting on it.
Hell Has Dropped Out of the Picture
The research also points to something deeper underneath those numbers. In the broader culture, the plausibility structure for hell has collapsed.
Two generations ago, hell was a live category in everyday imagination — feared, joked about, argued over, but real. Today it has receded into something more like a metaphor, or an embarrassment. People don't expect hell because they no longer think of themselves the way Scripture describes them — as sinners, genuinely in need of rescue. In this same survey, 23% of Americans actively disagreed with the simple statement "I am a sinner." That's the soil the less-than-1% grows in. If you don't believe you're a sinner, hell isn't a threat — it's an irrelevance.
John speaks to the 23%: "If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us" (1 John 1:8). The very next verse holds out the promise that if we confess our sins, God is faithful and just to forgive us. Forgiveness means something only to a person who knows they need it. Jesus said He came to call sinners, the same way a doctor comes for the sick rather than the healthy (Luke 5:31–32). When people stop seeing themselves as sick, they stop looking for the Physician, and that's what our numbers suggest is happening across much of the country.
One in Four Is Still Asking
There's another number in this research that gives me real hope. A full 25% of Americans told us they're not sure what happens when they die. I see that as an open door for churches and ministries.
One in four Americans is carrying an honest, unresolved question about eternity — the most important question a human being can carry — and waiting for someone to engage it without flinching. The danger isn't only that they're drifting toward self-salvation. It's that the church too often answers the question they're not asking (institutional belonging) instead of the question they are asking (what awaits me, and on what basis).
The honest read from our research is that Americans haven't rejected grace. Many of them have simply never had it explained in a way that distinguishes respect for Jesus from trust in Jesus.
That distinction reminds me of Nicodemus. Nicodemus respected Jesus. He was a religious leader, a teacher himself, and by any outside measure a good man. Yet Jesus told him he needed to be born again. Admiring Jesus as a great teacher wasn't the same as trusting Him for new life. A few verses later comes the promise many of us memorized as children: whoever believes in Him will not perish but have eternal life (John 3:16).
I suspect many of the people in our survey are standing where Nicodemus stood. They think well of Jesus. What they need is someone to explain, patiently and clearly, why He came and what it means to put their full trust in Him.
While the data should sober us, the harvest is still in the field. Jesus looked out at the crowds and told His disciples, "The harvest is plentiful, but the laborers are few" (Matthew 9:37). Our research tells me that's as true in America today as it was in Galilee.
What This Asks of Us
So what do we do with this?
First, settle the question for yourself. If you're not certain where you'll spend eternity, or if you've been quietly counting on being a decent person, I'd encourage you to read Ephesians 2:1–10 slowly this week. Paul lays out the whole story there: our condition apart from Christ, God's rich mercy, and salvation as a gift received by grace through faith.
Second, be ready for the conversation. Peter tells us to always be prepared to give a reason for the hope we have, and to do it with gentleness and respect (1 Peter 3:15). Statistically, one in four of the people you work with, live next to, or sit beside at your kids' ballgames is unsure about eternity. Many of them would welcome an honest conversation if someone took the time to have it.
Third, if you're a pastor or ministry leader, take a close look at what your people are hearing. Ask whether your preaching and teaching make clear the difference between admiring Jesus and trusting Him. That's part of why we developed the SALT Index (Scripture Absorption and Life Transformation), a research-based framework that measures spiritual growth across dimensions such as Scripture engagement, obedience, Christlike character, and relational impact. The Christian life can't be reduced to numbers, but this kind of insight can help churches see where their people are, strengthen discipleship, identify needs, and celebrate real transformation.
I didn't share these findings to discourage you. I shared them because the question of eternity is still on people's minds, and God has given us the answer in His Word. Our job is to open it and explain it, clearly and lovingly, to the people around us.




Comments